Concepts in the Study of Religion


  • Equinox
    • Equinox Publishing Home
    • About Equinox
    • People at Equinox
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Statement
    • FAQ’s
  • Subjects
    • Archaeology & History
    • Linguistics & Communication
    • Popular Music
    • Religion & Philosophy
  • Journals
    • Journals Home Page
      • Archaeology and History Journals
      • Linguistics Journals
      • Popular Music Journals
      • Religious Studies Journals
    • Publishing For Societies
    • Librarians & Subscription Agents
    • Electronic Journal Packages
    • For Contributors
    • Open Access and Copyright Policy
    • Personal Subscriptions
    • Article Downloads
    • Back Issues
    • Pricelist
  • Books
    • Book Home Page
    • Forthcoming Books
    • Published Books
    • Series
      • Advances in CALL Research and Practice
      • Advances in Optimality Theory
      • Advances in the Cognitive Science of Religion
      • Allan Bennett, Bhikkhu Ananda Metteyya: Biography and Collected Writings
      • Applied Phonology and Pronunciation Teaching
      • British Council Monographs on Modern Language Testing
      • Collected Works of Christian M.I.M. Matthiessen
      • Collected Works of Ruqaiya Hasan
      • Communication Disorders & Clinical Linguistics
      • Comparative Research on Iconic and Performative Texts
      • Comparative Islamic Studies
      • Contemporary and Historical Paganism
      • Culture on the Edge
      • Discourses in Ancient Near Eastern and Biblical Studies
      • Discussions in Functional Approaches to Language
      • Eastern Buddhist Voices
      • Equinox English Linguistics and ELT
      • Equinox Textbooks and Surveys in Linguistics
      • Frameworks for Writing
      • Functional Linguistics
      • Genre, Music and Sound
      • Global Philosophy
      • Icons of Pop Music
      • J.R. Collis Publications
      • Key Concepts in Systemic Functional Linguistics
      • Middle Way Philosophy
      • Monographs in Arabic and Islamic Studies
      • Monographs in Islamic Archaeology
      • Monographs in Mediterranean Archaeology
      • Music Industry Studies
      • NAASR Working Papers
      • New Directions in Anthropological Archaeology
      • Oxford Centre for Buddhist Studies Monographs
      • Popular Music History
      • Pragmatic Interfaces
      • Reflective Practice in Language Education
      • Religion and the Senses
      • Religion in 5 Minutes
      • Southover Press
      • Studies in Ancient Religion and Culture
      • Studies in Applied Linguistics
      • Studies in Communication in Organisations and Professions
      • Studies in Egyptology and the Ancient Near East
      • Studies in Phonetics and Phonology
      • Studies in Popular Music
      • Studies in the Archaeology of Medieval Europe
      • Text and Social Context
      • The Early Settlement of Northern Europe
      • The Study of Religion in a Global Context
      • Themes in Qur’anic Studies
      • Transcultural Music Studies
      • Working with Culture on the Edge
      • Worlds of the Ancient Near East and Mediterranean
    • For Authors
    • E-Books
    • Textbooks
    • Book Trade
  • Resources
    • Events
    • Rights & Permissions
    • Advertisers & Media
  • Search
  • eBooks
Equinox Publishing
Books and Journals in Humanities, Social Science and Performing Arts
RSSTwitterFacebookLinkedInGoogle+

Enchantment

A Critical Primer

Ian Alexander Cuthbertson [+–]
Dawson College
Ian Alexander Cuthbertson is a professor in the Humanities Department at Dawson College in Montréal, Québec. Ian is broadly interested in exploring how the category “religion” is deployed to legitimize certain beliefs, practices, and institutions while delegitimizing others.

This book provides an overview of the various ways the concept enchantment and its related concepts disenchantment and re-enchantment have been employed both within religious studies scholarship and also in recent scholarship in the fields of philosophy, psychology, political science, and critical theory. Despite the prevalence of enchantment and its related concepts in contemporary scholarship, no introductory text on the subject of enchantment has yet been written. This book will be useful for students and scholars working on a variety of topics including religion in modernity, new religious movements, theories of secularization, environmentalism, and new materialism.

Series: Concepts in the Study of Religion

Table of Contents

Introduction

Why Enchantment? [+–]
In the introduction, I situate enchantment as a key concept for engaging with a wide range of conversations both within and outside religious studies scholarship including: descriptions of modernity; accounts of secularization; conflicts between science and religion; differences between pre-modern and modern religious forms; comparisons between pre-modern and modern societies and religious expressions, new materialisms, immanent justifications for environmentalism, and arguments concerning the place of religious justifications in legal proceedings.

Chapter 1

The Disenchantment Thesis and Pre-Modern Enchantment [+–]
In this chapter, I provide an overview of the disenchantment thesis. Popularized by Max Weber a century ago and developed more recently by Marcel Gauchet, Charles Taylor, and others, the disenchantment thesis argues that specific modern developments have caused irreversible intellectual and affective changes such that modern individuals prefer scientific explanations over magical ones and are increasingly immune to feelings of fullness, mystery, and awe. Using the disenchantment thesis as a reference point, I also present a brief account of the kinds of pre-modern enchantments that are presumed to have existed prior to the alleged disenchantment of the world.

Chapter 2

Disenchantment as Modern Myth [+–]
In this chapter, I present an overview of several recent arguments against the disenchantment thesis. I question the historical bases for claims that pre-modernity was in fact enchanted, discuss the continued global prevalence of religious belief and affiliation, and consider sociological evidence that points to the continued relevance and popularity of supernatural beliefs and practices such as belief in ghosts and spirits, the popularity of astrology, and the prevalence of contemporary magical thinking.

Chapter 3

Disenchantment as Disqualification [+–]
In this chapter, I consider recent arguments that the discourse of disenchantment primarily serves to disparage or disqualify specific groups or segments of society including women, children, people of colour, members of the so-called developing world, and individuals who live in the rural areas. From this perspective, disenchantment is less a claim about historical processes than a marker of difference used to separate imagined rational, modern, and civilized persons from imagined irrational, backward and deluded others. I also argue that processes of disenchantment are both popular and satisfying precisely because they provide a feeling of intellectual superiority to anyone who questions the apparent superstitions or delusions of others.

Chapter 4

Re-Enchantment: New Religious Movements, Paganisms, and the Occult [+–]
In this chapter, I build on themes raised in chapter two and engage with recent scholarship that describes the contemporary world as re-enchanted. This version of re-enchantment largely accepts the disenchantment thesis but points to the growth of new religious movements (e.g. Scientology, Wicca), the resurgence of various forms of paganism (e.g. Druidism), and renewed interest in occult practices (e.g. tarot cards, spirit mediums) as evidence that the disenchantment of the world is reversible.

Chapter 5

Re-Enchantment: Delight without Delusion [+–]
In this chapter, I engage with recent scholarship that distinguishes between re-enchantment as a return of magical beliefs and practices explored in chapter four and apparently secular enchantments. This version of re-enchantment considers the popularity of fantasy literature and films (e.g. Harry Potter), the enduring appeal of stage magic shows, and other sources of peak experiences (e.g. festivals such as Burning Man, a sense of wonder in natural settings) as evidence that although widespread belief in magic may have declined, attempts to enjoy the affective dimensions of enchantment (wonder, awe) remain prevalent in modern secular societies.

Chapter 6

Modern Enchantment: Half-Belief, Irony, and Play [+–]
In the final chapter, I present my own theoretical interventions in the study of enchantment, disenchantment, and re-enchantment. First, I argue that rather than viewing enchantment/re-enchantment and disenchantment in terms of an either/or binary, it is more fruitful to consider enchantment as a spectrum. In this view, individuals are never either fully enchanted or disenchanted but instead engage with or reject ‘magical’ beliefs and practices depending on the particular circumstances in they find themselves. Second, I argue that whether or not the disenchantment thesis provides and accurate account of historical developments, the discourse of disenchantment sets limits on the kinds of beliefs and practices individuals are willing to publicly admit entertaining. According to this view, ironic engagement with magical practices constitutes a valid form of modern enchantment. Finally, I argue that considering engagement with magical beliefs and practices through the lens of a playful, subjunctive ‘what if’ attitude creates a theoretical space in which to consider individuals who may deny the efficacy of magical beliefs and practices while nevertheless playfully engaging with these.

Conclusion

The Future of Enchantment [+–]
In the conclusion, I argue that recent attempts to ‘reclaim’ enchantment and to free the concept from its associations with magical thinking and delusion are largely misguided. Instead, I argue that related terms (awe, wonder) could easily replace enchantment and insist the concept’s dual nature (both magical thinking and delight) is precisely what makes it such a useful concept for understanding the forms of contemporary belief and practice explored in the final chapter.

ISBN-13 (Hardback)
9781000000000
Price (Hardback)
£60.00 / $80.00
ISBN-13 (Paperback)
9781000000000
Price (Paperback)
£21.95 / $27.95
ISBN (eBook)
9781000000000
Price (eBook)
Individual
£21.95 / $27.95
Institutional
£60.00 / $80.00
Publication
01/07/2023
Pages
200
Size
216 x 140mm
Readership
students

Related Journal

Related Interest

,a href="https://www.equinoxpub.com/home/comparison/">

  • Search Equinox

  • Subjects

    • Archaeology & History
      • Food History
      • Journals
    • Linguistics & Communication
      • Spanish & Arabic
      • Writing & Composition
      • Journals
    • Popular Music
      • Jazz
      • Journals
    • Religion & Philosophy
      • Buddhist Studies
      • Islamic Studies
      • Journals
  • Tweets by @EQUINOXPUB
We may use cookies to collect information about your computer, including where available your IP address, operating system and browser type, for system administration and to report aggregate information for our internal use. Find out more.